Goodbye freeloading, hello free thinking; the Travel Foundation asks “Who pays?”

May 26, 2018

Little Venice quay flooded with tourists
Click here for your invitation to write for "Good Tourism" ... Feel free to pass it on.

When you next go on vaca­tion, who will pay?

It’s a simple ques­tion and you may think the answer is obvi­ous: you, the customer.

But are trav­el­lers cov­er­ing their costs?

Experts at a roundtable event organ­ised by Cor­nell Uni­ver­sity were asked that ques­tion and they answered with a resound­ing “no”.

All those around the table — aca­dem­ics and rep­res­ent­at­ives from busi­nesses and des­tin­a­tions — accep­ted that tour­ism isn’t pay­ing its way.

Our industry is under­valu­ing its shared products — the des­tin­a­tion “assets” vis­it­ors enjoy, such as beaches, biod­iversity, her­it­age sites and infrastructure.

How has this come about? Some of the reas­ons include:

  • Res­id­ents foot­ing the bill for shared infra­struc­ture. For instance, in Rhodes Island, Greece, one research study found loc­als were unwit­tingly sub­sid­ising the cost of energy dur­ing the tour­ism sea­son, by an estim­ated €20 million.
  • Under­in­vest­ment in des­tin­a­tion main­ten­ance (with most tax rev­en­ues being diver­ted to mar­ket­ing and promotion).
  • Eco­nom­ic “leak­age”, where as much as 80% of tour­ism rev­en­ue leaves the coun­try due to taxes, wages, and profits being paid out­side of a coun­try, and due to import­ing food and oth­er goods.
  • Gov­ern­ment sub­sidies and tax incent­ives which dis­tort the com­mer­cial costs of tourism.

The res­ult for des­tin­a­tions can be seen across the world as has been high­lighted by the media recently. Islands have closed to tour­ism in Thai­l­and and the Phil­ip­pines due to envir­on­ment­al con­cerns. And res­id­ents in many European cit­ies have acted out over what has been described as “over­tour­ism”.

So how can we ensure des­tin­a­tions can bal­ance their books across their triple bot­tom line (social, envir­on­ment­al, financial)?

A 2017 WTTC report (linked below) pro­posed we should account for des­tin­a­tion main­ten­ance and sus­tain­ab­il­ity and set prices accord­ingly (referred to as the “actu­al” cost). Such a pro­pos­al may seem pain­fully obvi­ous, and yet its inclu­sion in the report tells us how far we, as an industry, must go.

Cornell’s roundtable par­ti­cipants viewed the con­tinu­ing growth of glob­al tour­ism as an oppor­tun­ity to cre­ate a fun­da­ment­al shift in how it oper­ates, con­sid­er­ing innov­a­tions such as bet­ter valu­ation of des­tin­a­tion assets, B Corp busi­ness mod­els, dif­fer­ent fund­ing approaches, and stronger loc­al governance.

The Travel Found­a­tion is now work­ing with Cor­nell and its Sus­tain­able Tour­ism Asset Man­age­ment Pro­gram, led by Megan Epler Wood, to pro­duce a joint report that will make the case for bet­ter des­tin­a­tion man­age­ment, and describe how organ­isa­tions can make the transition.

The Sus­tain­able Tour­ism Entre­pren­eur­ship and Des­tin­a­tion Asset Man­age­ment Roundtable was organ­ized by the Pills­bury Insti­tute for Hos­pit­al­ity Entre­pren­eur­ship at Cor­nell Uni­ver­sity on May 3 2018. The roundtable was part of the Sus­tain­able Tour­ism Asset Man­age­ment Pro­gram at Cornell.

Fea­tured image: Little Venice quay flooded with tour­ists. Mykonos island, Cyc­lades, Agean Sea, Greece. By Mstyslav Chernov (CC BY-SA 3.0) via Wiki­me­dia.

Downloads

About the Author

Ben Lynam
Ben Lynam

Ben Lynam is Head of Com­mu­nic­a­tions at the Travel Found­a­tion.

Related posts

Follow comments on this post
Please notify me of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.