Islands of darkness: Ireland’s ‘Alcatraz’ and the growth of dark tourism

October 15, 2017

Spike Island is part of the growth of dark tourism

Click here for your invitation to write for "Good Tourism" ... Feel free to pass it on.
By Gil­lian O’Bri­en, Read­er in Mod­ern Irish His­tory, Liv­er­pool John Moores Uni­ver­sity, writ­ing for The Conversation.

Spike Island—the former fort­ress and pris­on off the coast of County Cork in Ire­land — has been named Europe’s lead­ing tour­ist attrac­tion at the World Travel Awards. The island beat off com­pet­i­tion from Buck­ing­ham Palace, the Eif­fel Tower and Rome’s Colos­seum to win what is described as the “Oscars” of the travel industry. It is a win for the com­munity and also a win for so called “dark tour­ism”, whereby trav­el­lers seek some­thing a tad more macabre than the tra­di­tion­al trip to the seaside.

There is no doubt Spike Island has a fas­cin­at­ing his­tory. Situ­ated in Cork Har­bour, one of the largest nat­ur­al har­bours in the world, it has been home to a mon­ast­ic set­tle­ment, a mil­it­ary fort­ress and a pris­on. Since the fort­ress reopened to vis­it­ors in June 2016, it has become a pop­u­lar tour­ist des­tin­a­tion, attract­ing over 45,000 vis­it­ors this year.

Vis­it­ors travel by boat from the town of Cobh to the island where they can explore the star-shaped fort which was home to thou­sands of sol­diers and pris­on­ers from the late 18th-cen­tury until 2004. There they learn about the his­tory of the island, from its place as a home to early Chris­ti­an monks, through the key stra­tegic role it played dur­ing the French Revolu­tion­ary Wars and the Napo­leon­ic Era, to its rein­carn­a­tion as an island pris­on in the 19th, 20th and 21st centuries.

The growth of ‘dark tourism’

Spike Island is one of a grow­ing num­ber of attrac­tions in Ire­land that can be called “dark tour­ism” sites. Dark tour­ism is closely asso­ci­ated with death, suf­fer­ing and the macabre. The concept is far from new; Madame Tus­saud became fam­ous in Par­is dur­ing the French Revolu­tion when she cast wax­work death masks of the guil­lotined and by the 1830s she was exhib­it­ing wax­works of mur­der­ers in London.

Growth of dark tourism. Robben Island, South Africa

Off the coast of Cape Town, South Africa, lies Rob­ben Island, where Nel­son Man­dela was incar­cer­ated. South Afric­an Tour­ism (CC BY 2.0) via Flickr.

In my book, Blood Runs Green, I wrote about the pub­lic fas­cin­a­tion with death, and par­tic­u­larly bru­tal death, in Gil­ded Age Amer­ica. In Chica­go in 1889, thou­sands of “dark tour­ists” paid a dime to vis­it the house where a man had been bludgeoned to death and a fur­ther dime to take away souven­ir shards of blood-stained wood (no one seemed to notice that far more splin­ters of wood were sold than had been neces­sary to build the house).

Aca­dem­ic stud­ies of “dark tour­ism” have ten­ded to focus on sites asso­ci­ated with the holo­caust; par­tic­u­larly con­cen­tra­tion camps such as Aus­chwitz. But some research has been con­duc­ted on pris­on islands, not­ably Rob­ben Island off the coast of Cape Town, South Africa, which was home to Nel­son Man­dela for 18 of his 27 years in pris­on. Oth­er stud­ies have looked at Alc­a­t­raz, the fam­ous pris­on island in San Fran­cisco Bay. Both sites have key dom­in­ant stor­ies: The image of Alc­a­t­raz is dom­in­ated by Hol­ly­wood vis­ions of the island pris­on, while Rob­ben Island is most closely asso­ci­ated with the polit­ic­al pris­on­ers of the apartheid regime. Both sites make efforts to expand the vis­it­or exper­i­ence bey­ond these nar­row his­tor­ies, but with lim­ited suc­cess in the pub­lic perception.

Responsible tourism

Part of my role as the his­tor­ic­al advisor for the Spike Island Pro­ject was to con­sider issues asso­ci­ated with rep­res­ent­ing incar­cer­a­tion, pun­ish­ment and exe­cu­tion. His­tory should be neither san­it­ised nor sen­sa­tion­al­ised. Dark tour­ist sites are often temp­ted to provide the gory details of exe­cu­tions, high­light escape attempts and focus on the bru­tal­ity of jail­ers. But it is also import­ant to con­sider the vic­tims of crime and the ways in which their exper­i­ence might be mar­gin­al­ised when sites focus on the sensational.

Our pro­ject iden­ti­fied four key nar­rat­ives that would allow the social, polit­ic­al and mil­it­ary his­tor­ies of the island to be told: Cork Har­bour, the Island Fort­ress, the Island Pris­on and the Island Home. Our inten­tion was not to priv­ilege one theme or story, but to offer vis­it­ors a multi-layered exper­i­ence that revealed a diversity of voices ran­ging right across the island’s past.

Growth of dark tourism. Alcatraz, USA

Alc­a­t­raz Island in San Fran­cisco Bay, Cali­for­nia, USA. By Cent­pacrr (CC BY-SA 3.0) via Wiki­me­dia.

Tour­ism is a busi­ness and com­mer­cial real­it­ies are a factor in devel­op­ing any tour­ist site. Sites need to make money and it is the respons­ib­il­ity of the design team to make the con­tent as access­ible and as inter­est­ing as pos­sible. Unlike Alc­a­t­raz, Spike Island had few fam­ous pris­on­ers and has not been immor­tal­ised in Hol­ly­wood films. As the his­tor­i­an respons­ible for research­ing and writ­ing the island’s story, this was a good thing, as it enabled me to tell the whole story of the island as a place of refuge, defence and of incarceration.

Vis­it­ors can wander through the remains of the island vil­lage and ima­gine grow­ing up on an island com­plete with its own school, church, fort­ress and pris­on. They can walk the cor­ridors of the pris­on and stand in the cold, damp cells. They can patrol the peri­met­er of the fort­ress and ima­gine defend­ing Cork har­bour from a flo­tilla of invad­ing ships. These are the types of exper­i­ences that can­not be rep­lic­ated in a pur­pose-built museum.

The chal­lenge of telling com­plex and diverse stor­ies in a com­pel­ling and attract­ive way is a con­sid­er­able one and involves input from a lot of people. But I believe that Spike Island suc­cess­fully treads the fine line between edu­ca­tion, enter­tain­ment and sen­sa­tion. It is neither exploit­at­ive nor does it shy away from its dif­fi­cult past.

The ConversationThis art­icle by Gil­lian O’Bri­en, Read­er in Mod­ern Irish His­tory at Liv­er­pool John Moores Uni­ver­sity, was ori­gin­ally pub­lished on The Con­ver­sa­tion (CC BY-ND 4.0. The “GT” Blog used a dif­fer­ent head­line and images). The author was the his­tor­ic­al con­sult­ant for the devel­op­ment of Phase I of Fort­ress Spike Island.

Fea­tured image: The 24-acre star-shaped Fort Mitchel on Spike Island was at the bleed­ing edge of mil­it­ary tech­no­logy when it was com­pleted around 1850. The points of the star allowed defend­ers to arc fire over all parts of the island, mak­ing the whole island a kill zone. Source: Spike Island.

Related posts

Follow comments on this post
Please notify me of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.